I like these better than any of the last three pair of "work" boots I have purchased. I got so tired of name brand work boots falling apart quickly I started cycling older waterproof hiking boots into work settings as I replaced them with new hikers. I took a chance on these.Pro -- They are made of good quality leather. The leather accepted leather dressing without issues and looks great.- They required little break in and do not rub anywhere, including my bunion.- The shaft is snug fitting and comes up a true 6 inches. They did not skimp on the tongue or its attachments. There is enough leather in the shaft to lace properly without gapping, unlike a pair of boots I ended up returning.- The sole and insole feel almost like a tennis shoe, and the energy flex function seems to work.- The boots in general, and the toe box, feel slightly wide. Not sloppy, but generous. If you need that it's a plus. They would accommodate heavy socks or thicker insoles.Cons -- The arch support is a bit weak, and I have to lace up tightly to get the support I feel like I need.- The soles have been a little slippery on an oily surface. This might be because they are new and not scuffed in.- Laces are already fraying a bit. They may not last.Unless something changes I would recommend and buy again.